Rep. Norm Thurston — Voting Record

Utah House District 62 · complete roll-call record from le.utah.gov
← All votes

Bill

Software in Education Amendments
Number
S.B. 267 (2026GS)
Sponsor
Sen. Cullimore, Kirk A.
Final action
Governor Signed 3/18/2026
Outcome
Became law — signed by Gov. Spencer J. Cox

Summary

This bill requires the State Board of Education (state board) to study best practices regarding the use of software in public schools.

What it does

  • This bill:
  • defines terms;
  • requires the state board to:
  • conduct a study regarding the use of software and digital services in public schools;
  • review best practices related to the educational effectiveness, design, and data practices of software that students use;
  • publish guidance describing best practices for the responsible use of software in a public school; and
  • upon request, report the findings of the study to the Education Interim Committee; and
  • makes technical and conforming changes.

Every vote on this bill

2026-02-19Senate Comm - Substitute Recommendation
Senate Education Committee
5-0-2not eligible / no record
2026-02-19Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation
Senate Education Committee
5-1-1not eligible / no record
2026-03-04House Comm - Amendment Recommendation
House Education Committee
8-0-7not eligible / no record
2026-03-04House Comm - Favorable Recommendation
House Education Committee
9-0-6not eligible / no record
2026-02-26Senate/ passed 2nd reading
Senate 3rd Reading Calendar
23-3-3not eligible / no record
2026-03-05House/ circled
House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-03-05House/ uncircled
House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-03-05House/ substituted
House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-03-05House/ passed 3rd reading
Senate Secretary
70-1-4YEA
2026-03-05House/ motion to reconsider
Clerk of the House
55-17-3YEA
2026-03-05House/ circled
House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-03-05House/ uncircled
House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-03-05House/ floor amendment
House 3rd Reading Calendar for Senate bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-03-05House/ passed 3rd reading
Senate Secretary
65-1-9YEA
2026-02-27Senate/ circled
Senate 3rd Reading Calendar
0-0-29not eligible / no record
2026-03-03Senate/ uncircled
Senate 3rd Reading Calendar
0-0-29not eligible / no record
2026-03-03Senate/ substituted
Senate 3rd Reading Calendar
0-0-29not eligible / no record
2026-03-03Senate/ passed 3rd reading
Clerk of the House
24-3-2not eligible / no record
2026-03-06Senate/ concurs with House amendment
House Speaker
28-1-0not eligible / no record

Bill text

enrolled version · official source
36
53E-1-201
53E-3-527
53E-1-201
53E-3-527
0
Software in Education Amendments
2026 GENERAL SESSION
STATE OF UTAH
Chief Sponsor: Kirk A. Cullimore
House Sponsor: Doug Fiefia
Cosponsor:
Brady Brammer
LONG TITLE
General Description:
This bill requires the State Board of Education (state board) to study best practices 
regarding the use of software in public schools.
Highlighted Provisions:
This bill:
defines terms;
requires the state board to:
conduct a study regarding the use of software and digital services in public schools;
review best practices related to the educational effectiveness, design, and data 
practices of software that students use;
publish guidance describing best practices for the responsible use of software in a 
public school; and
upon request, report the findings of the study to the Education Interim Committee; and
makes technical and conforming changes.
Money Appropriated in this Bill:
None
Other Special Clauses:
This bill provides a special effective date.
Utah Code Sections Affected:
AMENDS:
53E-1-201
Effective 
07/01/26
Partially Repealed 
07/01/27
 , as last amended by Laws 
of Utah 2025, First Special Session, Chapter 9
ENACTS:
53E-3-527
Effective 
07/01/26
 , Utah Code Annotated 1953
Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:
Section 1. Section 
53E-1-201
 is amended to read:
53E-1-201
Effective 
07/01/26
Partially Repealed 
07/01/27
. Reports to and 
action required of the Education Interim Committee.
(1)
In accordance with applicable provisions and Section 
68-3-14
, the following recurring 
reports are due to the Education Interim Committee:
(a)
the report described in Section 
9-22-109
 by the STEM Action Center Board, 
including the information described in Section 
9-22-113
 on the status of the computer 
science initiative and Section 
9-22-114
 on the Computing Partnerships Grants 
Program;
(b)
the prioritized list of data research described in Section 
53H-15-303
 and the report 
on research and activities described in Section 
53H-15-305
 by the Utah Data 
Research Center;
(c)
the report described in Section 
53H-1-203
 by the Utah Board of Higher Education on 
career and technical education issues and addressing workforce needs;
(d)
the annual report of the Utah Board of Higher Education described in Section 
53H-1-203
;
(e)
the reports described in Section 
53H-7-603
 by the Utah Board of Higher Education 
regarding activities related to campus safety;
(f)
the State Superintendent's Annual Report by the state board described in Section 
53E-1-203
;
(g)
the annual report described in Section 
53E-2-202
 by the state board on the strategic 
plan to improve student outcomes;
(h)
the report described in Section 
53E-3-501
 by the state board on students in an LEA 
who receive academic credit through the packet method;
(i)
the report described in Section 
53E-8-204
 by the state board on the Utah Schools for 
the Deaf and the Blind;
(j)
the report described in Section 
53E-10-703
 by the Utah Leading through Effective, 
Actionable, and Dynamic Education director on research and other activities;
(k)
the report described in Section 
53F-2-522
 regarding mental health screening 
programs;
(l)
the report described in Section 
53F-4-203
 by the state board and the independent 
evaluator on an evaluation of early interactive reading software;
(m)
the report described in Section 
53F-6-412
 by the program manager of the Utah Fits 
All Scholarship Program;
(n)
the report described in Section 
63N-20-107
 by the Governor's Office of Economic 
Opportunity on UPSTART;
(o)
the report described in Section 
53F-5-215
 by the state board related to a grant for an 
elementary teacher preparation assessment;
(p)
upon request, the report described in Section 
53F-5-219
 by the state board on the 
Local Innovations Civics Education Pilot Program;
(q)
the report described in Section 
53F-5-405
 by the state board regarding an evaluation 
of a partnership that receives a grant to improve educational outcomes for students 
who are low-income;
(r)
the report described in Section 
53H-1-604
 regarding the Higher Education and 
Corrections Council;
(s)
the report described in Section 
53G-7-221
 by the state board regarding innovation 
plans; and
(t)
the reports described in Section 
53F-6-412
 regarding the Utah Fits All Scholarship 
Program.
(2)
In accordance with applicable provisions and Section 
68-3-14
, the following occasional 
reports are due to the Education Interim Committee:
(a)
in 2027, 2030, 2033, and 2035, the reports described in Sections 
53H-1-502
, 
53H-1-503
, and 
53H-1-504
;
(b)
in 2025, the report described in Section 
53H-6-203
 by a degree-granting institution 
regarding policies on abusive coaching practices;
(c)
upon request, the report described in Section 
53E-3-527
 by the state board regarding 
the study on software in a public school;
(c)
(d)
if required, the report described in Section 
53E-4-309
 by the state board 
explaining the reasons for changing the grade level specification for the 
administration of specific assessments;
(d)
(e)
if required, the report described in Section 
53E-5-210
 by the state board of an 
adjustment to the minimum level that demonstrates proficiency for each statewide 
assessment;
(e)
(f)
the report described in Section 
53E-10-702
 by Utah Leading through Effective, 
Actionable, and Dynamic Education;
(f)
(g)
if required, the report described in Section 
53F-2-513
 by the state board 
evaluating the effects of salary bonuses on the recruitment and retention of effective 
teachers in high-poverty schools;
(g)
(h)
upon request, the report described in Section 
53F-10-303
 by the state board 
regarding the Rural School Sports Facilities Grant Program;
(h)
(i)
upon request, a report described in Section 
53G-7-222
 by an LEA regarding 
expenditure of a percentage of state restricted funds to support an innovative 
education program;
(i)
(j)
the reports described in Section 
53G-11-304
 by the state board regarding 
proposed rules and results related to educator exit surveys; and
(j)
(k)
the report described in Section 
26B-5-113
 by the Office of Substance Use and 
Mental Health, the state board, and the Department of Health and Human Services 
regarding recommendations related to Medicaid reimbursement for school-based 
health services.
(3)
In accordance with applicable provisions and Section 
68-3-14
, every five years the 
Education Interim Committee shall review the programs described in the following 
sections of code:
(a)
beginning July 1, 2027, 
Title 
53E, Chapter 10, Part 3
, 
Chapter 10, Part 3, 
Concurrent Enrollment;
(b)
beginning July 1, 2027, Section 
53F-2-408
, Enhancement for Accelerated Students 
Program;
(c)
beginning July 1, 2027, Section 
53F-2-409
, Concurrent enrollment funding;
(d)
beginning July 1, 2027, Section 
53F-2-415
, Student health and counseling support -- 
Qualifying personnel -- Distribution formula -- Rulemaking;
(e)
beginning July 1, 2028, Section 
53F-2-416
, Appropriation and distribution for the 
Teacher and Student Success Program;
(f)
beginning July 1, 2028, Section 
53F-2-510
, Digital Teaching and Learning Grant 
Program;
(g)
beginning July 1, 2028, Section 
53F-9-306
, Teacher and Student Success Account;
(h)
beginning July 1, 2028, Title 
53G, Chapter 7, Part 13
, Teacher and Student Success 
Program; and
(i)
beginning July 1, 2029, Section 
53F-2-502
, Dual language immersion.
Section 2. Section 
53E-3-527
 is enacted to read:
53E-3-527
Effective 
07/01/26
. Software in public schools study.
(1)
As used in this section:
(a)
"Academic progress" means advancement toward mastery of state academic 
standards through practice, application, feedback, or demonstration of knowledge or 
skill.
(b)
"Academically effective" means software that:
(i)
is designed to provide support or enable a student's active learning, skill 
development, or academic progress in the intended subject area;
(ii)
where applicable, aligns with the public education core standards described in 
Section 
53E-4-202
;
(iii)
does not employ design features that primarily:
(A)
interfere with active learning; or
(B)
undermine teacher instructional authority; and
(iv)
contributes to or enables measurable academic progress or skill development 
when used as intended.
(c)
"Active learning" means instruction that requires a student to engage in cognitive 
processes including analyzing, reasoning, practicing, or creating to understand or 
apply knowledge or skills.
(d)
(i)
"Addictive design feature" means a feature or component of a digital or online 
product that encourages or increases a student's frequency, time spent, or 
engagement with the product.
(ii)
"Addictive design feature" includes the following features:
(A)
infinite scroll;
(B)
autoplay that continues beyond the educational task or lesson;
(C)
points, badges, or other gamification rewards tied to time spent on the product 
rather than learning objectives or academic progress;
(D)
persistent notifications prompting re-engagement when the product is not 
actively in use, unless:
(I)
a teacher initiates the notification; and
(II)
the notification is directly related to assigned schoolwork;
(E)
personalized recommendation systems designed to maximize 
time-on-platform rather than learning outcomes; or
(F)
engagement metrics, streaks, or social comparison features designed to create 
fear of missing out or compulsive checking behavior.
(iii)
"Addictive design feature" does not include a:
(A)
recommendation of next lessons or learning activities based on curriculum 
progression or mastery of prerequisites;
(B)
notification about a teacher-assigned or course-required assignment, deadline, 
or teacher feedback; or
(C)
feature that encourages active learning rather than passive consumption.
(e)
"Clickstream data" means data an LEA or third-party provider collects from a 
student's use of an online service, application, or device that records the student's 
navigation or sequence of actions.
(f)
"Digital privacy agreement" means a contract between a contracting entity and a 
digital provider that:
(i)
ensures compliance with Chapter 9, Student Privacy and Data Protection; and
(ii)
governs access, use, protection, retention, and disclosure of student data.
(g)
"Educational software" means software that:
(i)
serves an educational purpose; and
(ii)
is designed for student instruction, assessment, or instructional support.
(h)
"Passive consumption" means receiving information through viewing, listening, or 
browsing without requiring the student to engage in cognitive processing necessary to 
analyze, apply, or create knowledge or skills.
(i)
"School-issued device" means any electronic hardware device an LEA provides to a 
student for educational use.
(j)
"Skill development" means the acquisition or improvement of academic abilities or 
competencies necessary to perform a task aligned to state academic standards, 
including guided practice, modeling, or feedback.
(k)
(i)
"Software" means any application, web-based service, plug-in, or other 
code-based product, regardless of whether the application is free or for purchase, 
that:
(A)
runs on or is accessible from a school-issued device; and
(B)
an LEA assigns, requires, recommends, installs, or otherwise makes available 
for student use in connection with classroom instruction, including through a 
school-issued account or identity, regardless of whether the software is 
accessible on a school-issued or student-owned device.
(ii)
"Software" includes software an individual uses during school hours in 
connection with school-related purposes for:
(A)
instruction;
(B)
assessment;
(C)
communication;
(D)
collaboration; or
(E)
enrichment.
(iii)
"Software" does not include physical, electronic hardware.
(l)
(i)
"Student data" means the same as that term is defined in Section 
53E-9-301
.
(ii)
"Student data" includes a student's:
(A)
personal data as that term is defined in Section 
13-61-101
;
(B)
metadata, device identifiers, and clickstream data;
(C)
behavioral, engagement, or usage data; and
(D)
information a software collects, generates, or infers in the course of student 
use.
(m)
"Sub-processor" means a third-party vendor or service that a primary data processor 
engages to process personal data on the processor's behalf.
(2)
The state board shall conduct a study regarding the use of software and digital services 
in public schools and identify best practices related to student learning, safety, and 
privacy.
(3)
In conducting the study described in Subsection 
(2)
, the state board:
(a)
shall review and evaluate best practices related to:
(i)
the academic effectiveness of educational software, including whether software 
supports:
(A)
active learning;
(B)
skill development; and
(C)
measurable academic progress;
(ii)
the potential use, cost, benefits, and drawbacks of a single, statewide digital 
privacy agreement for all educational software used in a public school;
(iii)
alignment of educational software with state academic standards;
(iv)
the role of educational software in supporting or supplementing classroom 
instruction;
(v)
the distinction between active learning and passive consumption in digital 
learning tools;
(vi)
compliance with the sensitive materials requirements described in Section 
53G-10-103
 as the requirements relate to the use of software in a school;
(vii)
digital privacy practices for student data, including:
(A)
data minimization;
(B)
security safeguards;
(C)
breach notification practices;
(D)
data retention and deletion practices; and
(E)
limits on secondary use of student data;
(viii)
the collection and use of student data, including:
(A)
metadata;
(B)
clickstream data;
(C)
behavioral or engagement data; and
(D)
biometric identifiers;
(ix)
practices related to protecting a student from:
(A)
advertising or promotional content;
(B)
commercial exploitation of student data; and
(C)
algorithmic systems that may prioritize engagement over learning outcomes;
(x)
educational software design practices that may affect student engagement, 
including the use of addictive design features;
(xi)
transparency regarding:
(A)
data the software collects;
(B)
third-party service providers or sub-processors; and
(C)
embedded analytics or artificial intelligence systems;
(xii)
the use of device features including
 cameras or microphones in educational 
software;
(xiii)
best practices for evaluating the educational value of educational software; and
(xiv)
any other issue the state board determines relevant to the responsible use of 
software in public education; and
(b)
may consult with:
(i)
educators;
(ii)
LEAs;
(iii)
parents;
(iv)
technology and software providers;
(v)
researchers;
(vi)
institutions of higher education; and
(vii)
other stakeholders the state board determines to be appropriate.
(4)
Before July 1, 2027, the state board shall:
(a)
publish on the state board's website guidance and best practices identified through 
the study described in this section; and
(b)
distribute the guidance and best practices to each LEA.
(5)
Upon the request of the Education Interim Committee, the state board shall provide a 
report summarizing the study and the guidance described in Subsection 
(4)
 to the 
Education Interim Committee.
Section 3. 
Effective Date.
This bill takes effect on 
July 1, 2026
.
3-12-26 10:24 AM