Rep. Norm Thurston — Voting Record

Utah House District 62 · complete roll-call record from le.utah.gov
← All votes

Bill

Wrongful Lien Act Amendments
Number
S.B. 196 (2026GS)
Sponsor
Sen. Ipson, Don L.
Final action
Governor Signed 3/23/2026
Outcome
Became law — signed by Gov. Spencer J. Cox

Summary

This bill amends provisions related to wrongful liens.

What it does

  • This bill:
  • expands the definition of "wrongful lien";
  • provides that if a notice of transfer fee covenant is a wrongful lien, the notice of transfer fee covenant is invalid;
  • provides that a county recorder is not required to determine whether a notice of transfer fee covenant is a wrongful lien under certain circumstances; and
  • makes technical changes.

Every vote on this bill

2026-02-12Senate Comm - Substitute Recommendation
Senate Business and Labor Committee
5-0-3not eligible / no record
2026-02-12Senate Comm - Amendment Recommendation
Senate Business and Labor Committee
5-0-3not eligible / no record
2026-02-12Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation
Senate Business and Labor Committee
5-0-3not eligible / no record
2026-03-02House Comm - Substitute Recommendation
House Political Subdivisions Committee
10-0-2not eligible / no record
2026-03-02House Comm - Favorable Recommendation
House Political Subdivisions Committee
10-0-2not eligible / no record
2026-02-24Senate/ passed 2nd reading
Senate 3rd Reading Calendar
23-0-6not eligible / no record
2026-02-25Senate/ passed 3rd reading
Clerk of the House
27-0-2not eligible / no record
2026-03-06House/ passed 3rd reading
Senate Secretary
68-1-6ABSENT
2026-03-06Senate/ concurs with House amendment
House Speaker
27-0-2not eligible / no record

Bill text

enrolled version · official source
17
38-9-102
57-1-46
57-1-47
0
Wrongful Lien Act Amendments
2026 GENERAL SESSION
STATE OF UTAH
Chief Sponsor: Don L. Ipson
House Sponsor: R. Neil Walter
LONG TITLE
General Description:
This bill amends provisions related to wrongful liens.
Highlighted Provisions:
This bill:
expands the definition of "wrongful lien";
provides that if a notice of transfer fee covenant is a wrongful lien, the notice of transfer 
fee covenant is invalid;
provides that a county recorder is not required to determine whether a notice of transfer 
fee covenant is a wrongful lien under certain circumstances; and
makes technical changes.
Money Appropriated in this Bill:
None
Other Special Clauses:
None
Utah Code Sections Affected:
AMENDS:
38-9-102
, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2025, First Special Session, Chapter 15
57-1-46
, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2025, Chapter 226
57-1-47
, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2024, Chapter 431
Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:
Section 1. Section 
38-9-102
 is amended to read:
38-9-102
. Definitions.
As used in this chapter:
(1)
"Affected person" means:
(a)
a person who is a record interest holder of the real property that is the subject of a 
recorded nonconsensual common law document; or
(b)
the person against whom a recorded nonconsensual common law document purports 
to reflect or establish a claim or obligation.
(2)
"Document sponsor" means a person who, personally or through a designee, signs or 
submits for recording a document that is, or is alleged to be, a nonconsensual common 
law document.
(3)
"Interest holder" means a person who holds or possesses a present, lawful property 
interest in 
certain 
real property, including an owner, 
a 
title holder, 
a 
mortgagee,
 a
trustee, or 
a 
beneficial owner.
(4)
"Lien claimant" means a person claiming an interest in real property who offers a 
document for recording or filing with 
any
a
 county recorder in the state asserting a lien, 
or notice of interest, or other claim of interest in 
certain 
real property.
(5)
"Nonconsensual common law document" means a document that is submitted to a 
county recorder's office for recording against public official property that:
(a)
purports to create a lien or encumbrance on or a notice of interest in the real property;
(b)
at the time the document is recorded, is not:
(i)
expressly authorized by this chapter or a state or federal statute;
(ii)
authorized by or contained in an order or judgment of a court 
of competent
with
jurisdiction; or
(iii)
signed by or expressly authorized by a document signed by the owner of the real 
property; and
(c)
is submitted in relation to the public official's status or capacity as a public official.
(6)
"Owner" means a person who has a vested ownership interest in real property.
(7)
"Political subdivision" means a county, city, town, school district, special improvement 
or taxing district, special district, special service district, or other governmental 
subdivision or public corporation.
(8)
"Public official" means:
(a)
a current or former:
(i)
member of the Legislature;
(ii)
member of Congress;
(iii)
judge;
(iv)
member of law enforcement;
(v)
corrections officer;
(vi)
active member of the Utah State Bar; or
(vii)
member of the Board of Pardons and Parole;
(b)
an individual currently or previously appointed or elected to an elected position in:
(i)
the executive branch of state or federal government; or
(ii)
a political subdivision;
(c)
an individual currently or previously appointed to or employed in a position in a 
political subdivision, or state or federal government that:
(i)
is a policymaking position; or
(ii)
involves:
(A)
purchasing or contracting decisions;
(B)
drafting legislation or making rules;
(C)
determining rates or fees; or
(D)
making adjudicative decisions; or
(d)
an immediate family member of a person described in Subsections 
(8)(a)
 through 
(c)
.
(9)
"Public official property" means real property that has at least one record interest holder 
who is a public official.
(10)
(a)
"Record interest holder" means a person who holds or possesses a present, lawful 
property interest in real property, including an owner, titleholder, mortgagee, trustee, 
or beneficial owner, and whose name and interest in that real property appears in the 
county recorder's records for the county in which the property is located.
(b)
"Record interest holder" includes 
any
a
 grantor in the chain of the title in real 
property.
(11)
"Record owner" means an owner whose name and ownership interest in 
certain 
real 
property is recorded or filed in the county recorder's records for the county in which the 
property is located.
(12)
(a)
"Wrongful lien" means 
any
a
 document that purports to create a lien, notice of 
interest, or encumbrance on an owner's interest in 
certain 
real property and at the 
time 
it
the document
 is recorded is not:
(i)
expressly authorized by this chapter or another state or federal statute;
(ii)
authorized by or contained in an order or judgment of a court 
of competent
with
jurisdiction in the state; or
(iii)
signed by or authorized in accordance with a document signed by the owner of 
the real property.
(b)
"Wrongful lien" includes
:
(i)
a document recorded in violation of Subsection 
10-20-508(2)(d)
.
; or
(ii)
a document that purports to be a notice of transfer fee covenant described in 
Subsection 
57-1-46(7)
 or Section 
57-1-47
 or a document that purports to create, 
continue, or reestablish a transfer fee covenant as a lien or encumbrance on an 
owner's interest in real property, if at the time the document was recorded the 
transfer fee covenant was not enforceable due to the:
(A)
foreclosure of a trust deed or mortgage that has priority over the transfer fee 
covenant;
(B)
absence of a previously recorded notice of transfer fee covenant required by 
Subsection 
57-1-46(7)
 or Section 
57-1-47
; or
(C)
existence of a recorded rescission, termination, release, waiver, or other 
document terminating the transfer fee covenant.
Section 2. Section 
57-1-46
 is amended to read:
57-1-46
. Transfer fee and reinvestment fee covenants.
(1)
As used in this section:
(a)
"Association expenses" means expenses incurred by a common interest association 
for:
(i)
the purchase, ownership, leasing, construction, operation, use, administration, 
maintenance, improvement, repair, or replacement of association facilities, 
including expenses for taxes, insurance, operating reserves, capital reserves, and 
emergency funds;
(ii)
providing, establishing, creating, or managing a facility, activity, service, or 
program for the benefit of property owners, tenants, common areas, the burdened 
property, or property governed by the common interest association; or
(iii)
other facilities, activities, services, or programs that are required or permitted 
under the common interest association's organizational documents.
(b)
"Association facilities" means any real property, improvements on real property, or 
personal property owned, leased, constructed, developed, managed, or used by a 
common interest association, including common areas.
(c)
"Association transfer fee" means a fee, charge, or payment that is:
(i)
related to the sale of real property; and
(ii)
as a result of a transfer of the real property, is imposed on a buyer or seller by:
(A)
a common interest association; or
(B)
a person acting on behalf of the common interest association.
(d)
"Burdened property" means the real property that is subject to a reinvestment fee 
covenant or transfer fee covenant.
(e)
"Common areas" means areas described within:
(i)
the definition of "common areas and facilities" under Section 
57-8-3
; and
(ii)
the definition of "common areas" under Section 
57-8a-102
.
(f)
(i)
"Common interest association" means:
(A)
an association, as defined in Section 
57-8a-102
;
(B)
an association of unit owners, as defined in Section 
57-8-3
; or
(C)
a nonprofit association.
(ii)
"Common interest association" includes a person authorized by an association, 
association of unit owners, or nonprofit association.
(g)
"Large master planned development" means an approved development:
(i)
of at least 500 acres or 500 units; and
(ii)
that includes a commitment to fund, construct, develop, or maintain:
(A)
common infrastructure;
(B)
association facilities;
(C)
community programming;
(D)
resort facilities;
(E)
open space; or
(F)
recreation amenities.
(h)
"Nonprofit association" means a nonprofit corporation organized under Title 16, 
Chapter 6a, Utah Revised Nonprofit Corporation Act, to benefit, enhance, preserve, 
govern, manage, or maintain burdened property.
(i)
"Organizational documents" means:
(i)
for an association, as defined in Section 
57-8a-102
, governing documents as 
defined in Section 
57-8a-102
;
(ii)
for an association of unit owners, as defined in Section 
57-8-3
, a declaration as 
defined in Section 
57-8-3
; and
(iii)
for a nonprofit association:
(A)
a written instrument by which the nonprofit association exercises powers or 
manages, maintains, or otherwise affects the property under the jurisdiction of 
the nonprofit association; and
(B)
articles of incorporation, bylaws, plats, charters, the nonprofit association's 
rules, and declarations of covenants, conditions, and restrictions.
(j)
"Reinvestment fee" means a fee imposed, directly or indirectly, by a common interest 
association:
(i)
upon a buyer or seller of real property;
(ii)
upon and as a result of a transfer of the real property; and
(iii)
that is dedicated to benefiting the common areas, including payment for:
(A)
common planning, facilities, and infrastructure;
(B)
obligations arising from an environmental covenant;
(C)
community programming;
(D)
resort facilities;
(E)
open space;
(F)
recreation amenities;
(G)
charitable purposes; or
(H)
association expenses.
(k)
"Reinvestment fee covenant" means a covenant, restriction, or agreement that:
(i)
affects real property; and
(ii)
obligates a future buyer or seller of the real property to pay to a common interest 
association, upon and as a result of a transfer of the real property, a fee that is 
dedicated to benefitting the burdened property, including payment for:
(A)
common planning, facilities, and infrastructure;
(B)
obligations arising from an environmental covenant;
(C)
community programming;
(D)
resort facilities;
(E)
open space;
(F)
recreation amenities;
(G)
charitable purposes; or
(H)
association expenses.
(l)
"Transfer fee covenant":
(i)
means an obligation, however denominated, expressed in a covenant, restriction, 
agreement, or other instrument or document:
(A)
that affects real property;
(B)
that is imposed on a future buyer or seller of real property, other than a person 
who is a party to the covenant, restriction, agreement, or other instrument or 
document; and
(C)
to pay a fee upon and as a result of a transfer of the real property; and
(ii)
does not include:
(A)
an obligation imposed by a court judgment, order, or decree;
(B)
an obligation imposed by the federal government or a state or local 
government entity; or
(C)
a reinvestment fee covenant.
(2)
A transfer fee covenant recorded on or after March 16, 2010, is void and unenforceable.
(3)
(a)
Except as provided in Subsection 
(3)(b)
, a reinvestment fee covenant may not be 
sold, assigned, or conveyed unless the sale, assignment, or conveyance is to a 
common interest association that was formed to benefit the burdened property.
(b)
A common interest association may assign or pledge to a lender the right to receive 
payment under a reinvestment fee covenant if:
(i)
the assignment or pledge is as collateral for a credit facility; and
(ii)
the lender releases the collateral interest upon payment in full of all amounts that 
the common interest association owes to the lender under the credit facility.
(4)
A reinvestment fee covenant recorded on or after March 16, 2010, is not enforceable if 
the reinvestment fee covenant is intended to affect property that is the subject of a 
previously recorded transfer fee covenant or reinvestment fee covenant.
(5)
A reinvestment fee covenant recorded on or after March 16, 2010, may not obligate the 
payment of a fee that exceeds .5% of the value of the burdened property, unless the 
burdened property is part of a large master planned development.
(6)
(a)
A reinvestment fee covenant recorded on or after March 16, 2010, is void and 
unenforceable unless a notice of reinvestment fee covenant, separate from the 
reinvestment fee covenant, is recorded in the office of the recorder of each county in 
which any of the burdened property is located.
(b)
A notice under Subsection 
(6)(a)
 shall:
(i)
state the name and address of the common interest association to which the fee 
under the reinvestment fee covenant is required to be paid;
(ii)
include the notarized signature of the common interest association's authorized 
representative;
(iii)
state that the burden of the reinvestment fee covenant is intended to run with the 
land and to bind successors in interest and assigns;
(iv)
state that the existence of the reinvestment fee covenant precludes the imposition 
of an additional reinvestment fee covenant on the burdened property;
(v)
state the duration of the reinvestment fee covenant;
(vi)
state the purpose of the fee required to be paid under the reinvestment fee 
covenant; and
(vii)
state that the fee required to be paid under the reinvestment fee covenant is 
required to benefit the burdened property.
(c)
A recorded notice of reinvestment fee covenant that substantially complies with the 
requirements of Subsection 
(6)(b)
 is valid and effective.
(7)
(a)
A reinvestment fee covenant or transfer fee covenant recorded before March 16, 
2010, is not enforceable after May 31, 2010, unless:
(i)
a notice that is consistent with the notice described in Subsection 
(6)
 is recorded in 
the office of the recorder of each county in which any of the burdened property is 
located; or
(ii)
a notice of reinvestment fee covenant or transfer fee covenant, as described in 
Subsection 
(7)(b)
, is recorded in the office of the recorder of each county in which 
any of the burdened property is located.
(b)
A notice under Subsection 
(7)(a)(ii)
 shall:
(i)
include the notarized signature of the beneficiary of the reinvestment fee covenant 
or transfer fee covenant, or the beneficiary's authorized representative;
(ii)
state the name and current address of the beneficiary under the reinvestment fee 
covenant or transfer fee covenant;
(iii)
state that the burden of the reinvestment fee covenant or transfer fee covenant is 
intended to run with the land and to bind successors in interest and assigns; and
(iv)
state the duration of the reinvestment fee covenant or transfer fee covenant.
(c)
(i)
A recorded notice of reinvestment fee covenant or transfer fee covenant that 
substantially complies with the requirements of Subsection 
(7)(b)
 is valid and 
effective
, unless the notice of transfer fee covenant is a wrongful lien as that term 
is defined in Section 
38-9-102
.
(ii)
A county recorder is not required to determine whether a notice of transfer fee 
covenant is a wrongful lien for purposes of this Subsection 
(7)(c)
.
(d)
A notice under Subsection 
(7)(b)
:
(i)
that is recorded after May 31, 2010, is not enforceable; and
(ii)
shall comply with the requirements of Section 
57-1-47
.
(e)
An amendment to a notice under Subsection 
(7)(b)
 recorded after May 31, 2010, 
seeking to amend a notice under Subsection 
(7)(b)
 recorded before May 31, 2010, is 
not an enforceable amendment.
(8)
A reinvestment fee covenant recorded on or after March 16, 2010, may not be enforced 
upon:
(a)
an involuntary transfer;
(b)
a transfer that results from a court order;
(c)
a bona fide transfer to a family member of the seller within three degrees of 
consanguinity who, before the transfer, provides adequate proof of consanguinity;
(d)
a transfer or change of interest due to death, whether provided in a will, trust, or 
decree of distribution; or
(e)
the transfer of burdened property by a financial institution, except to the extent that 
the reinvestment fee covenant requires the payment of a common interest 
association's costs directly related to the transfer of the burdened property, not to 
exceed $250.
(9)
An association transfer fee imposed on or after May 7, 2025, is void and unenforceable 
unless the association uses the fee only to pay expenses related to the transfer.
(10)
On or after May 7, 2025, an association may not impose a reinvestment fee unless:
(a)
imposing the reinvestment fee is authorized in the declaration or a reinvestment fee 
covenant; and
(b)
a majority of voting interests in the association, or a higher percentage if required in 
the organizational documents, approves the reinvestment fee.
(11)
After a vote approving the reinvestment fee described in Subsection 
(10)(b)
, an 
association may set the amount of a reinvestment fee only:
(a)
in accordance with the terms of the declaration or a reinvestment fee covenant; and
(b)
upon providing notice in accordance with Section 
57-8a-214
.
(12)
Members of the association may remove or amend a reinvestment fee by holding a 
vote at a special meeting:
(a)
called by the members for the purpose of removing or amending the reinvestment 
fee; and
(b)
at which:
(i)
at least 51% of the voting interests attend and vote; and
(ii)
a majority of the voting interests that attend vote to remove or amend the 
reinvestment fee.
Section 3. Section 
57-1-47
 is amended to read:
57-1-47
. Notice requirements for continuation of existing private transfer fee 
obligations.
(1)
In addition to the requirements described in Subsection 
57-1-46(7)
, a person required to 
file a notice under this section shall:
(a)
(i)
file the notice described in this section on or before May 31, 2024; and
(ii)
re-file the notice, no earlier than May 1 and no later than May 31, every three 
years thereafter; and
(b)
amend the notice to reflect any change in the name or address of any payee included 
in the notice no later than the 30 days after the day on which the change occurs.
(2)
A person who amends a notice filed under Subsection 
(1)
 shall include with the 
amendment:
(a)
the recording information of the original notice; and
(b)
the legal description of the property subject to the private transfer fee obligation.
(3)
To be effective, a notice filed under this section shall be approved in writing by every 
person holding a majority of the beneficial interests in the private transfer fee obligation.
(4)
If a person required to file a notice under this section fails to comply with this section:
(a)
payment of the private transfer fee may not be a requirement for the conveyance of 
an interest in the property to a purchaser;
(b)
the property is not subject to further obligation under the private transfer fee 
obligation; and
(c)
the private transfer fee obligation is void.
(5)
(a)
A recorded notice of transfer fee covenant that complies with the requirements of 
this section is valid and effective
, unless the notice of transfer fee covenant is a 
wrongful lien as that term is defined in Section 
38-9-102
.
(b)
A county recorder is not required to determine whether a notice of transfer fee 
covenant is a wrongful lien for purposes of this Subsection 
(5)
.
(6)
(a)
A person that is no longer subject to a private transfer fee obligation may seek 
declaratory relief in court to address any encumbrance on real property owned by the 
person.
(b)
Upon a successful claim for declaratory relief, as described in Subsection 
(6)(a)
, a 
court may award the person costs and reasonable attorney fees.
(7)
This section does not apply to a reinvestment fee covenant, as that term is defined in 
Section 
57-1-46
.
Section 4. 
Effective Date.
This bill takes effect on 
May 6, 2026
.
3-10-26 9:36 AM