Rep. Norm Thurston — Voting Record

Utah House District 62 · complete roll-call record from le.utah.gov
← All votes

Bill

District Court Amendments
Number
H.B. 392 (2026GS)
Sponsor
Rep. MacPherson, Matt
Final action
Governor Signed 2/13/2026
Outcome
Became law — signed by Gov. Spencer J. Cox

Summary

This bill addresses civil actions in the district court.

What it does

  • This bill:
  • grants the attorney general an unconditional right to intervene in a civil action in the district court upon notice that a party is challenging the constitutionality of a statute;
  • provides that the Utah Supreme Court has exclusive and original appellate jurisdiction over a judgment or order from a panel of three district court judges;
  • provides that the attorney general, the governor, or the Legislature may file a notice to convene a three-judge panel in a civil action in the district court;
  • requires a panel of three district court judges to be convened to hear and decide a civil action upon the filing of a notice to convene a district court panel;
  • requires each judge of a district court panel to be randomly selected and from a different judicial district than the other judges on the panel;
  • addresses the structure and voting process for a district court panel;
  • provides that the statutory venue requirements for a civil action do not apply to an action before a district court panel;
  • requires the Judicial Council to create a rule regarding the random selection process for a judge on a district court panel;
  • addresses staffing of a district court panel; and
  • makes technical and conforming changes.

Every vote on this bill

2026-01-28House Comm - Favorable Recommendation
House Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice Committee
7-2-2not eligible / no record
2026-02-05Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation
Senate Revenue and Taxation Committee
4-1-2not eligible / no record
2026-02-03House/ circled
House 3rd Reading Calendar for House bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-02-03House/ uncircled
House 3rd Reading Calendar for House bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-02-03House/ substituted
House 3rd Reading Calendar for House bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-02-03House/ circled
House 3rd Reading Calendar for House bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-02-04House/ uncircled
House 3rd Reading Calendar for House bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-02-04House/ substituted
House 3rd Reading Calendar for House bills
0-0-75not eligible / no record
2026-02-04House/ passed 3rd reading
Senate Secretary
56-15-4YEA
2026-02-11Senate/ substituted
Senate 2nd Reading Calendar
0-0-29not eligible / no record
2026-02-11Senate/ passed 2nd reading
Senate 3rd Reading Calendar
21-7-1not eligible / no record
2026-02-13House/ concurs with Senate amendment
Senate President
55-16-4YEA
2026-02-12Senate/ passed 3rd reading
Clerk of the House
22-7-0not eligible / no record

Bill text

enrolled version · official source
16
67-5-41
78A-3-102
78A-5-102.7
78B-3a-102
0
District Court Amendments
2026 GENERAL SESSION
STATE OF UTAH
Chief Sponsor: Matt MacPherson
Senate Sponsor: Michael K. McKell
LONG TITLE
General Description:
This bill addresses civil actions in the district court.
Highlighted Provisions:
This bill:
grants the attorney general an unconditional right to intervene in a civil action in the 
district court upon notice that a party is challenging the constitutionality of a statute;
provides that the Utah Supreme Court has exclusive and original appellate jurisdiction 
over a judgment or order from a panel of three district court judges;
provides that the attorney general, the governor, or the Legislature may file a notice to 
convene a three-judge panel in a civil action in the district court;
requires a panel of three district court judges to be convened to hear and decide a civil 
action upon the filing of a notice to convene a district court panel;
requires each judge of a district court panel to be randomly selected and from a different 
judicial district than the other judges on the panel;
 addresses the structure and voting process for a district court panel;
provides that the statutory venue requirements for a civil action do not apply to an action 
before a district court panel;
requires the Judicial Council to create a rule regarding the random selection process for a 
judge on a district court panel;
addresses staffing of a district court panel; and
makes technical and conforming changes.
Money Appropriated in this Bill:
None
Other Special Clauses:
This bill provides a special effective date.
Utah Code Sections Affected:
AMENDS:
78A-3-102
, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2025, Second Special Session, Chapter 3
78B-3a-102
, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2023, Chapter 401
ENACTS:
67-5-41
, Utah Code Annotated 1953
78A-5-102.7
, Utah Code Annotated 1953
Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:
Section 1. Section 
67-5-41
 is enacted to read:
67-5-41
. Right to intervene in action challenging constitutionality of a statute.
(1)
The attorney general has an unconditional right to intervene in a civil action in a district 
court upon receiving a notice under Rule 24 of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure that a 
party is challenging the constitutionality of a statute in the civil action.
(2)
Intervention by the attorney general in accordance with Subsection 
(1)
 does not limit the 
Legislature's unconditional right to intervene under Subsection 
36-12-7(4)
.
Section 2. Section 
78A-3-102
 is amended to read:
78A-3-102
. Jurisdiction of Supreme Court.
(1)
The Supreme Court has original jurisdiction to answer questions of state law certified 
by a court of the United States.
(2)
The Supreme Court has original jurisdiction to issue all extraordinary writs and 
authority to issue all writs and process necessary to carry into effect the Supreme Court's 
orders, judgments, and decrees or in aid of the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
(3)
(a)
The Supreme Court has exclusive and original appellate jurisdiction, including 
exclusive and original appellate jurisdiction of an interlocutory appeal, over:
(i)
a judgment of the Court of Appeals;
(ii)
a case certified to the Supreme Court by the Court of Appeals before final 
judgment by the Court of Appeals;
(iii)
the discipline of a lawyer;
(iv)
a final order of the Judicial Conduct Commission;
(v)
an interlocutory appeal from a court of record involving a capital felony;
(vi)
an appeal from the district court involving a conviction or charge of a capital 
felony;
(vii)
an appeal from the district court of an order, judgment, or decree ruling on a 
legislative subpoena;
(viii)
an appeal of an injunctive order as described in Section 
78B-5-1002
;
(ix)
a judgment, or an interlocutory appeal of an order, of a district court involving:
(A)
an election or voting contest; or
(B)
the establishment of boundaries of political districts for purposes of an 
election;
 and
(x)
the retention or removal of a public officer
.
; and
(xi)
a judgment, or an interlocutory appeal of an order, from a district court panel 
described in Section 
78A-5-102.7
.
(b)
The Supreme Court may not transfer any matter described in Subsection 
(3)(a)
 to the 
Court of Appeals.
(c)
In a case involving an election or voting contest or the establishment of boundaries 
of political districts for purposes of an election, a judgment is appealable to the 
Supreme Court even if:
(i)
a party files a motion or claim for attorney fees under Rule 73 of the Utah Rules of 
Civil Procedure in the district court; and
(ii)
the district court has not entered a dispositive order for that motion or claim.
(4)
(a)
In addition to Subsection 
(3)(a)
, the Supreme Court has original appellate 
jurisdiction, including original appellate jurisdiction of an interlocutory appeal, over:
(i)
a final agency action, as described in Section 
63G-4-403
, in a formal adjudicative 
proceeding originating from:
(A)
the Public Service Commission;
(B)
the State Tax Commission;
(C)
the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees;
(D)
the Board of Oil, Gas, and Mining;
(E)
the state engineer; or
(F)
the executive director of the Department of Natural Resources reviewing an 
action of the Division of Forestry, Fire, and State Lands;
(ii)
a final order or decree of the district court review of an informal adjudicative 
proceeding of an agency described in Subsection 
(4)(a)(i)
;
(iii)
a final judgment or decree of a court of record holding a statute of the United 
States or this state is unconstitutional on its face under the Constitution of the 
United States or the Utah Constitution;
(iv)
an interlocutory appeal from a court of record involving a first degree felony;
(v)
an appeal from a district court involving a conviction or charge of a first degree 
felony; and
(vi)
an order, judgment, or decree of a court of record over which the Court of 
Appeals does not have appellate jurisdiction.
(b)
The Supreme Court may transfer any matter described in Subsection 
(4)(a)
 to the 
Court of Appeals.
(5)
(a)
The Supreme Court has sole discretion in granting or denying a petition for writ of 
certiorari for the review of a Court of Appeals adjudication.
(b)
Notwithstanding Subsection 
(5)(a)
, the Supreme Court shall review a case certified 
to the Supreme Court by the Court of Appeals under Subsection 
(3)(a)(ii)
.
(6)
The Supreme Court shall comply with the requirements of 
Title 63G, Chapter 4, 
Administrative Procedures Act
, in the Supreme Court's review of an agency adjudicative 
proceeding.
The following section is affected by a revisor instruction at the end of this bill.
Section 3. Section 
78A-5-102.7
 is enacted to read:
78A-5-102.7
. Three-judge panel in the district court -- Requirements.
(1)
As used in this section:
(a)
"Panel" means a panel of three district court judges that is convened under this 
section to hear and decide an action.
(b)
(i)
"State entity" means the state or any agency, department, board, or commission 
of the state.
(ii)
"State entity" includes the Legislature and any committee of the Legislature.
(c)
(i)
"State official" means an individual elected or appointed to a state office.
(ii)
"State official" includes:
(A)
a member of the Legislature;
(B)
the governor;
(C)
the lieutenant governor;
(D)
the state auditor;
(E)
the state treasurer; and
(F)
the attorney general.
(2)
(a)
If a civil action is brought in the district court and a state entity, or a state official 
in the state official's capacity, is a party to the civil action, the attorney general, the 
governor, or the Legislature may file a notice in the district court that a panel of three 
district court judges must be convened to hear and decide the civil action.
(b)
A notice to convene a panel under Subsection 
(2)(a)
:
(i)
may not be challenged by any party; and
(ii)
is not subject to judicial review.
(c)
(i)
The Legislature, a committee of the Legislature, or a member of the Legislature 
in the member's capacity, must
 be a party to the civil action for the Legislature to 
file a notice under Subsection 
(2)
(a).
(ii)
The governor, or a state official for the executive branch, must be a party to the 
civil action for the governor to file a notice under Subsection 
(2)
(a).
(iii)
The attorney general 
must be a party, or representing a party, to the civil action 
to file a notice under Subsection 
(2)
(a).
(d)
The time periods described in Rule 42 of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure apply to 
a notice described in this Subsection 
(2)
.
(3)
(a)
Upon the filing of a notice under Subsection 
(2)
, a panel of three district court 
judges shall hear and decide, by majority decision, the civil action in accordance with 
this section.
(b)
Each judge on a panel described in Subsection 
(3)(a)
 shall be:
(i)
selected at random; and
(ii)
from a different judicial district than the other judges on the panel.
(4)
(a)
The presiding officer of the Judicial Council shall select one judge assigned to a 
panel to be the chief judge of the panel.
(b)
Except as provided in Subsection 
(4)(c)
, the chief judge shall conduct all proceedings 
in an action before a panel.
(c)
A panel shall sit en banc for a trial, an order for an injunction or temporary 
restraining order, or any motion that would dispose of the action or any claim or 
defense in the action.
(d)
A judge on a panel may concur or dissent from any decision for which the panel sits 
en banc.
(5)
(a)
Title 78B, Chapter 3a, Venue for Civil Actions, does not apply to an action before 
a panel.
(b)
Any requirement in the Utah Code to file or bring an action in a specific district or 
county does not apply to an action before a panel.
(6)
(a)
Before March 7, 2026, the Judicial Council shall:
(i)
by rule, create a process by which a district court judge is assigned to a panel by 
random selection, including any reassignment of a district court judge on a panel 
due to disqualification, recusal, or a change of judge as a matter of right; and
(ii)
establish and maintain a list of judges who the Judicial Council determines are 
qualified to serve on a panel.
(b)
The list established under Subsection 
(6)(a)
 shall consist of at least 50% of the 
district court judges from each district.
(c)
The Judicial Council shall post the list described in Subsection 
(6)(a)
 on the website 
for the Utah state courts with information on the dates and number of times that a 
judge has served on a panel.
(7)
The Judicial Council shall hire a coordinator and staff to assist any panel convened 
under this section.
Section 4. Section 
78B-3a-102
 is amended to read:
78B-3a-102
. Applicability of this chapter -- Venue for the Business and 
Chancery Court.
(1)
Except as otherwise provided by another provision of the Utah Code, a plaintiff shall 
bring an action in accordance with the requirements of this chapter.
(2)
The requirements of this chapter do not apply to
:
(a)
an action brought in the Business and Chancery Court
.
; or
(b)
an action before a panel of judges in the district court under Section 
78A-5-102.7
.
Section 5. 
Effective Date.
This bill takes effect:
(1)
except as provided in Subsection (2), 
May 6, 2026
; or
(2)
if approved by two-thirds of all members elected to each house:
(a)
upon approval by the governor;
(b)
without the governor's signature, the day following the constitutional time limit of 
Utah Constitution, Article VII, Section 8; or
(c)
in the case of a veto, the date of veto override.
2-13-26 3:34 PM