Rep. Norm Thurston — Voting Record

Utah House District 62 · complete roll-call record from le.utah.gov
← All votes

Bill

School Children's Trust Section and Beneficiary Advocate Amendments
Number
H.B. 291 First Substitute (2017GS)
Sponsor
Rep. Noel, M.
Final action
House/ filed 3/9/2017
Outcome
Failed / filed without passage

Summary

This bill amends provisions regarding the School Children's Trust Section under the State Board of Education.

What it does

  • This bill:
  • provides that the director of the School Children's Trust Section:
  • shall take an oath of office as specified;
  • shall serve for a term of six years;
  • may serve multiple terms; and
  • is exempt from the Utah State Personnel Management Act;
  • amends the reasons for which the State Board of Education may remove the director of the School Children's Trust Section; and
  • requires the School Children's Trust Section to annually:
  • review each distribution recipient's compliance with applicable laws and rules; and
  • report any findings to the appropriate governing bodies.

Every vote on this bill

2/14/2017House Comm - Favorable Recommendation
House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment Committee
12 1 0not eligible / no record
2/27/2017House/ floor amendment failed
House 3rd Reading Calendar for House bills
Voice votenot eligible / no record
2/27/2017House/ floor amendment failed
House 3rd Reading Calendar for House bills
35 39 1YEA
2/27/2017House/ passed 3rd reading
Senate Secretary
48 27 0NAY
3/6/2017Senate Comm - Substitute Recommendation from # 0 to # 1
Senate Education Committee
4 0 3not eligible / no record
3/6/2017Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation
Senate Education Committee
5 0 2not eligible / no record

Bill text

introduced version · official source
SCHOOL AND INSTITUTIONAL TRUST LANDS
AMENDMENTS
GENERAL SESSION
STATE OF UTAH
Chief Sponsor: Michael E. Noel
Senate Sponsor: 
 Margaret Dayton
LONG TITLE
General Description:
This bill amends provisions regarding the School Children's Trust Section under the
State Board of Education.
Highlighted Provisions:
This bill:
▸ provides that the director of the School Children's Trust Section:
• shall take an oath of office as specified;
• shall serve for a term of six years;
• may serve multiple terms; and
• is exempt from the Utah State Personnel Management Act;
▸ amends the reasons for which the State Board of Education may remove the director
of the School Children's Trust Section; and
▸ requires the School Children's Trust Section to annually:
• review each distribution recipient's compliance with applicable laws and rules;
and
• report any findings to the appropriate governing bodies.
Money Appropriated in this Bill:
None
Other Special Clauses:
None
Utah Code Sections Affected:
AMENDS:
53A-16-101.6
 (Superseded 07/01/17)
, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2016, Chapter
144
53A-16-101.6
 (Effective 07/01/17)
, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2016, Chapters
144 and 172
53C-1-103
, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2012, Chapter 224
Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:
Section 1. Section 
53A-16-101.6 (Superseded 07/01/17)
 is amended to read:
53A-16-101.6 (Superseded 07/01/17).
Creation of School Children's Trust Section
-- Duties.
(1) As used in this section:
(a) "School and institutional trust lands" is as defined in Section 
53C-1-103
.
(b) "Section" means the School Children's Trust Section created in this section.
(c) "Trust" means:
(i) the School LAND Trust Program created in Section 
53A-16-101.5
; and
(ii) the lands and funds associated with the trusts described in Subsection
53C-1-103
(7).
(2) There is established a School Children's Trust Section under the State Board of
Education.
(3) (a) The section shall have [
a
] 
an independent
 director[
.
] 
who shall:
(i) act in a fiduciary capacity to the trust beneficiaries in accordance with the principles
set forth in Section 
53C-1-102
; and
(ii) take an oath of office before assuming the position of director as follows: "I
solemnly swear to carry out my duties as director of the School Children's Trust Section, with
undivided loyalty to the beneficiaries, to the best of my abilities and according to law."
(b) The director shall have professional qualifications and expertise in the areas
generating revenue to the trust, including:
(i) economics;
(ii) energy 
and mineral
 development;
(iii) finance;
(iv) investments;
(v) public education;
(vi) real estate;
(vii) renewable resources;
(viii) risk management; and
(ix) trust law.
(c) 
(i)
 The director shall
:
(A)
 be appointed as provided in this Subsection (3)[
.
]
; and
(B) except as provided in Subsection (3)(c)(ii), serve for a term of six years.
(ii) The six-year term of an individual who is the director on January 1, 2017, shall
expire on July 1, 2023, unless a vacancy occurs.
(iii) The director may serve more than one term.
(d) [
The
] 
When a vacancy for the position of director occurs, the
 School and
Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees nominating committee shall submit to the State
Board of Education the name of one person to serve as director.
(e) The State Board of Education may:
(i) appoint the person described in Subsection (3)(d) to serve as director; or
(ii) deny the appointment of the person described in Subsection (3)(d) to serve as
director.
(f) If the State Board of Education denies an appointment under this Subsection (3):
(i) the State Board of Education shall provide in writing one or more reasons for the
denial to the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees nominating committee;
and
(ii) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees nominating committee
and the State Board of Education shall follow the procedures and requirements of this
Subsection (3) until the State Board of Education appoints a director.
(g) 
(i)
 The State Board of Education may remove the director only
:
(A)
 by majority vote [
of a quorum
] 
of all the board members
 in an open and public
meeting after proper notice and the inclusion of the removal item on the agenda[
.
]
; and
(B) for neglect of fiduciary duty, malfeasance, gross negligence, or incapacitation.
(ii) The termination of an individual under this Subsection (3)(g) is effective
immediately and creates a vacancy in the position of the director.
(h) The position of director is exempt from the career service provisions of Title 67,
Chapter 19, Utah State Personnel Management Act.
(4) The State Board of Education shall make rules regarding:
(a) regular reporting from the School Children's Trust Section director to the State
Board of Education, to allow the State Board of Education to fulfill its duties in representing
the trust beneficiaries; and
(b) the day-to-day reporting of the School Children's Trust Section director.
(5) (a) The director shall annually submit a proposed section budget to the State Board
of Education.
(b) After approving a section budget, the State Board of Education shall 
annually:
(i) receive input on the director's performance from the chair of the board and director
of:
(A) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration; and
(B) the School and Institutional Trust Fund Office;
(ii) establish the range and compensation of the director in line with comparable
positions in state government, the responsibilities of the position, and the qualifications
required in Subsection (3)(b);
(iii) report the director's compensation to the Public Education Appropriations
Subcommittee; and
 (iv)
 propose the approved budget to the Legislature.
(6) The director is entitled to attend any presentation, discussion, meeting, or other
gathering concerning the trust, subject to:
(a) provisions of law prohibiting the director's attendance to preserve confidentiality; or
(b) other provisions of law that the director's attendance would violate.
(7) The section shall have a staff.
(8) The section shall protect current and future beneficiary rights and interests in the
trust consistent with the state's perpetual obligations under:
(a) the Utah Enabling Act;
(b) the Utah Constitution;
(c) state statute; and
(d) standard trust principles described in Section 
53C-1-102
.
(9) The section shall promote:
(a) productive use of school and institutional trust lands 
for the financial support of the
trust beneficiaries
; and
(b) the efficient and prudent investment of funds managed by the School and
Institutional Trust Fund Office, created in Section 
53D-1-201
.
(10) The section shall provide representation, advocacy, and input:
(a) on behalf of current and future beneficiaries of the trust, school community
councils, schools, and school districts;
(b) on federal, state, and local land decisions and policies that affect the trust; and
(c) to:
(i) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration;
(ii) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees;
(iii) the Legislature;
(iv) the School and Institutional Trust Fund Office, created in Section 
53D-1-201
;
(v) the School and Institutional Trust Fund Board of Trustees, created in Section
53D-1-301
;
(vi) the attorney general;
(vii) the public; and
(viii) other entities as determined by the section.
(11) The section shall provide independent oversight on the prudent and profitable
management of the trust and report annually to the State Board of Education and the
Legislature.
(12) The section shall provide information requested by a person or entity described in
Subsections (10)(c)(i) through (vii).
(13) (a) The section shall provide training to the entities described in Subsection
(13)(b) on:
(i) the School LAND Trust Program established in Section 
53A-16-101.5
; and
(ii) (A) a school community council established pursuant to Section 
53A-1a-108
; or
(B) a charter trust land council established under Section 
53A-16-101.5
.
(b) The section shall provide the training to:
(i) a local school board or a charter school governing board;
(ii) a school district or a charter school; and
(iii) a school community council.
(14) The section shall annually:
(a) review each trust distribution recipient's compliance with applicable law, including
applicable rules adopted by the State Board of Education; and
(b) report findings to the State Board of Education and other appropriate governing
bodies, including:
(i) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration created in Section
53C-1-201
 and the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees established in
Section 
53C-1-202
;
(ii) the School and Institutional Trust Fund Office created in Section 
53D-1-201
 and
the School and Institutional Trust Fund Board of Trustees created in Section 
53D-1-301
; and
(iii) other designated representatives and organizations of trust beneficiaries of school
and institutional trust lands.
Section 2. Section 
53A-16-101.6 (Effective 07/01/17)
 is amended to read:
53A-16-101.6 (Effective 07/01/17).
Creation of School Children's Trust Section --
Duties.
(1) As used in this section:
(a) "School and institutional trust lands" is as defined in Section 
53C-1-103
.
(b) "Section" means the School Children's Trust Section created in this section.
(c) "Trust" means:
(i) the School LAND Trust Program created in Section 
53A-16-101.5
; and
(ii) the lands and funds associated with the trusts described in Subsection
53C-1-103
(7).
(2) There is established a School Children's Trust Section under the State Board of
Education.
(3) (a) The section shall have [
a
] 
an independent
 director[
.
] 
who shall:
(i) act in a fiduciary capacity to the trust beneficiaries in accordance with the principles
set forth in Section 
53C-1-102
; and
(ii) take an oath of office before assuming the position of director as follows: "I
solemnly swear to carry out my duties as director of the School Children's Trust Section, with
undivided loyalty to the beneficiaries, to the best of my abilities and according to law."
(b) The director shall have professional qualifications and expertise in the areas
generating revenue to the trust, including:
(i) economics;
(ii) energy 
and mineral
 development;
(iii) finance;
(iv) investments;
(v) public education;
(vi) real estate;
(vii) renewable resources;
(viii) risk management; and
(ix) trust law.
(c) 
(i)
 The director shall
:
(A)
 be
 appointed as provided in this Subsection (3)[
.
]
; and
(B) except as provided in Subsection (3)(c)(ii), serve for a term of six years.
(ii) The six-year term of an individual who is the director on January 1, 2017, shall
expire on July 1, 2023, unless a vacancy occurs.
(iii) The director may serve more than one term.
(d) [
The
] 
When a vacancy for the position of director occurs, the
 School and
Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees nominating committee shall submit to the State
Board of Education the name of one person to serve as director.
(e) The State Board of Education may:
(i) appoint the person described in Subsection (3)(d) to serve as director; or
(ii) deny the appointment of the person described in Subsection (3)(d) to serve as
director.
(f) If the State Board of Education denies an appointment under this Subsection (3):
(i) the State Board of Education shall provide in writing one or more reasons for the
denial to the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees nominating committee;
and
(ii) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees nominating committee
and the State Board of Education shall follow the procedures and requirements of this
Subsection (3) until the State Board of Education appoints a director.
(g) 
(i)
 The State Board of Education may remove the director only
:
(A)
 by majority vote [
of a quorum
] 
of all the board members
 in an open and public
meeting after proper notice and the inclusion of the removal item on the agenda[
.
]
; and
(B) for neglect of fiduciary duty, malfeasance, gross negligence, or incapacitation.
(ii) The termination of an individual under this Subsection (3)(g) is effective
immediately and creates a vacancy in the position of the director.
(h) The position of director is exempt from the career service provisions of Title 67,
Chapter 19, Utah State Personnel Management Act.
(4) The State Board of Education shall make rules regarding:
(a) regular reporting from the School Children's Trust Section director to the State
Board of Education, to allow the State Board of Education to fulfill its duties in representing
the trust beneficiaries; and
(b) the day-to-day reporting of the School Children's Trust Section director.
(5) (a) The director shall annually submit a proposed section budget to the State Board
of Education.
(b) After approving a section budget, the State Board of Education shall 
annually:
(i) receive input on the director's performance from the chair of the board and director
of:
(A) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration; and
(B) the School and Institutional Trust Fund Office;
(ii) establish the range and compensation of the director in line with comparable
positions in state government, the responsibilities of the position, and the qualifications
required in Subsection (3)(b);
(iii) report the director's compensation to the Public Education Appropriations
Subcommittee; and
(iv)
 propose the approved budget to the Legislature.
(6) The director is entitled to attend any presentation, discussion, meeting, or other
gathering concerning the trust, subject to:
(a) provisions of law prohibiting the director's attendance to preserve confidentiality; or
(b) other provisions of law that the director's attendance would violate.
(7) The section shall have a staff.
(8) The section shall protect current and future beneficiary rights and interests in the
trust consistent with the state's perpetual obligations under:
(a) the Utah Enabling Act;
(b) the Utah Constitution;
(c) state statute; and
(d) standard trust principles described in Section 
53C-1-102
.
(9) The section shall promote:
(a) productive use of school and institutional trust lands 
for the financial support of the
trust beneficiaries
; and
(b) the efficient and prudent investment of funds managed by the School and
Institutional Trust Fund Office, created in Section 
53D-1-201
.
(10) The section shall provide representation, advocacy, and input:
(a) on behalf of current and future beneficiaries of the trust, school community
councils, schools, and school districts;
(b) on federal, state, and local land decisions and policies that affect the trust; and
(c) to:
(i) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration;
(ii) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees;
(iii) the Legislature;
(iv) the School and Institutional Trust Fund Office, created in Section 
53D-1-201
;
(v) the School and Institutional Trust Fund Board of Trustees, created in Section
53D-1-301
;
(vi) the attorney general;
(vii) the public; and
(viii) other entities as determined by the section.
(11) The section shall provide independent oversight on the prudent and profitable
management of the trust and report annually to the State Board of Education and the
Legislature.
(12) The section shall provide information requested by a person or entity described in
Subsections (10)(c)(i) through (vii).
(13) (a) The section shall provide training to the entities described in Subsection
(13)(b) on:
(i) the School LAND Trust Program established in Section 
53A-16-101.5
; and
(ii) (A) a school community council established pursuant to Section 
53A-1a-108
; or
(B) a charter trust land council established under Section 
53A-16-101.5
.
(b) The section shall provide the training to:
(i) a local school board or a charter school governing board;
(ii) a school district or a charter school; and
(iii) a school community council.
(14) The section shall annually:
(a) review each [
school's
] 
trust distribution recipient's
 compliance with applicable law,
including 
applicable
 rules adopted by the State Board of Education; and
(b) report findings to the State Board of Education[
.
] 
and other appropriate governing
bodies, including:
(i) the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration created in Section
53C-1-201
 and the School and Institutional Trust Lands Board of Trustees established in
Section 
53C-1-202
;
(ii) the School and Institutional Trust Fund Office created in Section 
53D-1-201
 and
the School and Institutional Trust Fund Board of Trustees created in Section 
53D-1-301
; and
(iii) other designated representatives and organizations of trust beneficiaries of school
and institutional trust lands.
Section 3. Section 
53C-1-103
 is amended to read:
53C-1-103.
Definitions.
As used in this title:
(1) "Administration" means the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration.
(2) "Board" or "board of trustees" means the School and Institutional Trust Lands
Board of Trustees.
(3) "Director" or "director of school and institutional trust lands" means the chief
executive officer of the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration.
(4) "Mineral" includes oil, gas, and hydrocarbons.
(5) "Nominating committee" means the committee that nominates candidates for
positions and vacancies on the board.
(6) "Policies" means statements applying to the administration that broadly prescribe a
future course of action and guiding principles.
(7) "Primary beneficiary representative" means the State Board of Education acting
with undivided loyalty consistent with the fiduciary duties and principles set forth in Section
53C-1-102
 for the financial support of and
 as representative on behalf of the following trusts:
(a) the trust established for common schools;
(b) the trust established for schools for the blind; and
(c) the trust established for schools for the deaf.
(8) "School and institutional trust lands" or "trust lands" means those properties
granted by the United States in the Utah Enabling Act to the state in trust, and other lands
transferred to the trust, which must be managed for the benefit of:
(a) the state's public education system; or
(b) the institutions of the state which are designated by the Utah Enabling Act as
beneficiaries of trust lands.
Legislative Review Note
Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel